Valuation for US Large Caps Has Never Been Higher
Historically the last show of the year I do my fearless forecast for the coming year. This year it’s bleak from a pure valuation perspective. But from a liquidity perspective, it’s up, up, and away. Our first table shows the Street has an average 23.69 multiple on 172.50 gives you an average S&P 500 target of 4085 for yearend 2021. JP Morgan is the high at 4400 with several at the low of 3800. The historic average is 16.5 and even if we account for the cheap cost of money and call it a 20x fair value multiple, we struggle to get to 3500. The market closed last week above 3700.
The next indicator in our PRO-II (Pro-Eyes) series looks at valuations today compared to history. There are many ways to look at valuation. My favourite is enterprise value to EBITDA. Enterprise value is the amount of capital the company has issued (debt plus equity less cash equivalents.) EBITDA is the earnings a company generates before interest and taxes are paid adjusting for non-cash items like depreciation and amortization. A measure like free cash flow that works for some industries better than others. Think about it this way: How much capital is at risk to generate free cash that the company can use to pay dividends or invest. We saw a valuation statistic table last week (shared below) that shows no matter how you measure US large caps, they are the most expensive they have ever been. Jay Powell, Chairman of the Federal Reserve, was asked in the Q&A last week about valuation. He chimed in with the same excuse we’ve been hearing from Wall Street. Interest rates are low, there is no alternative, the multiple should be higher. This behaviour by central banks and investors have made the US equity market more expensive than it’s ever been. History tells us this is not a good time to own stocks. But indicators like this are never good a timing sell signals, they just warn that timing is not ideal for buyers. And future returns on average will be well below historic averages. Everyone knows this, but few pay much attention.
Crescat Capital put together this table looking an many ways of valuing US large caps. Maybe it can go higher off the central bank printing press, but the slightest policy mistake reminds us that a correction can be significant. The degree of moral hazard priced into the equity market is colossal. There is NO debate here.
We have plotted EV to EBITDA on a trailing basis for the broad S&P 500 covering the past 30 years and 3 recessions. You can see the extreme nature of valuation over time. I’ve been concerned about valuations for several years. Since BREXIT in 2016 actually. We’ve had several violent corrections since then. The central bank printing press has brought the market back each time (the central banks call this financial conditions—read that as the S&P 500).
Look for more in the coming weeks from our new Berman’s Call Probable Return on Investment Index, PRO-II (pronounced Pro Eyes) Indicator. We will be launching the new website in early January so that BNN viewers can follow along with the various risk and opportunity factors we follow.
Subscribe to my new YouTube channel LarryBermanOfficial which is the new site for all our educational content and my new weekly market recap and ETF bull and bear picks of the week.
ETF Capital Management: www.etfcm.com